5141 Saint Albans Ave

SARASOTA, FL 34242

About this property

Tucked away on a quiet, tree-canopied street that sits high and did NOT flood, this Siesta Key property is more than a tropical retreat. It’s a rare opportunity to enjoy timeless island living today while unlocking tremendous future potential. Set on a nearly 10,000 sq ft lot with lush foliage and mature Live Oaks, this residence combines historic character, relaxed coastal charm, and valuable land in one of Sarasota’s most desirable neighborhoods. With no HOA or deed restrictions, you have the freedom to customize, expand, or build your dream home from the ground up, all just moments from the vibrant heart of Siesta Village and the world-famous shores of Siesta Beach. Inside, the home captures the spirit of island living with a unique wood-clad interior and vaulted ceilings that create an airy, perpetual vacation feel. Mornings are best spent on the screened porch overlooking swaying palms, while the spacious first-floor living and dining areas provide an inviting space for entertaining or unwinding after a day in the sun. The open kitchen features a 4-seat breakfast bar, and a guest bedroom with a full bathroom ensures comfort and flexibility on the main level. A laundry closet adds everyday convenience. Upstairs, the master loft serves as a secluded sanctuary with a cozy sitting area perfect for quiet reflection or remote work, along with an en-suite bathroom and walk-in closet. Recent updates, including new porch sliders and custom tile showers, add modern comfort while preserving the home’s rustic appeal. The 2015 A/C unit keeps the home comfortable year-round, and ample space for RVs or trailers adds versatility. Whether you fall in love with its historic charm or envision building a custom coastal masterpiece, this property offers a rare blend of present comfort and future potential in a premier Siesta Key location.

About this property

Tucked away on a quiet, tree-canopied street that sits high and did NOT flood, this Siesta Key property is more than a tropical retreat. It’s a rare opportunity to enjoy timeless island living today while unlocking tremendous future potential. Set on a nearly 10,000 sq ft lot with lush foliage and mature Live Oaks, this residence combines historic character, relaxed coastal charm, and valuable land in one of Sarasota’s most desirable neighborhoods. With no HOA or deed restrictions, you have the freedom to customize, expand, or build your dream home from the ground up, all just moments from the vibrant heart of Siesta Village and the world-famous shores of Siesta Beach. Inside, the home captures the spirit of island living with a unique wood-clad interior and vaulted ceilings that create an airy, perpetual vacation feel. Mornings are best spent on the screened porch overlooking swaying palms, while the spacious first-floor living and dining areas provide an inviting space for entertaining or unwinding after a day in the sun. The open kitchen features a 4-seat breakfast bar, and a guest bedroom with a full bathroom ensures comfort and flexibility on the main level. A laundry closet adds everyday convenience. Upstairs, the master loft serves as a secluded sanctuary with a cozy sitting area perfect for quiet reflection or remote work, along with an en-suite bathroom and walk-in closet. Recent updates, including new porch sliders and custom tile showers, add modern comfort while preserving the home’s rustic appeal. The 2015 A/C unit keeps the home comfortable year-round, and ample space for RVs or trailers adds versatility. Whether you fall in love with its historic charm or envision building a custom coastal masterpiece, this property offers a rare blend of present comfort and future potential in a premier Siesta Key location.

Features and Additional Information

Schedule a Tour
It's free and no obligation

Schedule a Private Showing

$764,000 Active
2 Bed(s)
2
Baths
1,131 sqft

Presented By Premier Key Realty

Agent Image
Get in touch today! Phone: 1-407-326-8826
Brokerage
BRIGHT REALTY
1-941-552-6036
Curious to find out what your home is worth?
Get My Home's Worth arrow_forward

Area Information

34242 Sarasota | Crescent Beach | Siesta Key | Sarasota County | SIESTA BEACH

$ 764,000
This listing is play_arrow 57.4% lower than the average in the area
$ 1,795,000 in the area
1,131 SqFt
This listing is play_arrow 59.1% smaller than the average in the area
2,767 SqFt in the area
$ 676 $/SqFt
This listing is play_arrow 4.1% more than the average in the area
$ 649 $/SqFt in the area
39 days on site
This listing is play_arrow 11.4% below the average in the area
44 days on site in the area

Schools in the Area

  • turned_in
    Elementary School
    Phillippi Shores Elementary
  • turned_in
    Middle School
    Brookside Middle
  • turned_in
    High School
    Sarasota High

Want to See More Listings in the Area?

Listed By Anthony Dalesandro
Brokerage: BRIGHT REALTY

Schedule a Private Showing

It's free and no obligation

Have Questions? Contact
Premier Key Realty

By submitting, you agree to receive promotional texts and/or calls from Premier Key Realty at the number provided. Message/data rates may apply. Consent is not a condition of purchase, and you can opt out anytime by replying STOP.
Real Estate Links Our Domains